Compare two positions on the same topic and assess the positions for logical argument with a basic worksheet. Pupils fill in information about each position, note down which position is more logical, and compose a few sentences explaining their choice. 

Concepts

compare and contrast, point of view

Show More Show Less

Additional Tags

point of view, compare and contrast, assess evidence, relevant evidence, evaluate argument, english language arts

Show More Show Less

Instructional Ideas

• Use this as a warm-up activity or preparation for a class discussion, debate, or argumentative essay

Classroom Considerations

• The exercise can be done with any text or texts of your choice

Pros

• Requires learners to justify their choice and explain their reasoning

Cons

• Some individuals may need additional scaffolding, especially for the explanatory portion

Common Core

RI.6.8 RI.7.8 RI.8.8 RI.9-10.8