Building Evidence-Based Arguments: "Search Warrant"

Is personal safety worth sacrificing privacy? Young citizens investigate the issue by examining the Fourth Amendment of the US Constitution and documents published by the Department of Justice, President George Bush, ACLU, Apple, and others. After researching the issue, pupils construct their own argumentative research papers to support their claims with textual evidence.

3 Views 1 Download
CCSS: Designed
Instructional Ideas

  • As an extension, have class members publish their writings in the school paper or a class blog
  • Consider having a debate about the issue to brainstorm a thesis statement for argumentative papers
Classroom Considerations

  • Some of the texts within the unit are rigorous; be sure to build in supports for struggling learners
Pros

  • Issue within the unit is relevant to pupils' lives
  • List of supplemental resources for the unit is well-constructed, uses mixed media, and mimics those on end-of-year state tests
  • Assessment options at the end of the unit are flexible to specific class's needs
Cons